Acne Scar Types: Which Treatment Suits Each Scar?
Ice pick, boxcar, rolling and raised acne scars each need a different treatment. See how to tell scar types apart, which treatments suit each one, how many sessions you need and what results to expect.

Quick Answer
- Ice pick scars: Narrow, deep holes. Treated with focused acid treatment or fine needling.
- Boxcar scars: Wide, flat-bottomed dents. Treated with RF microneedling or laser resurfacing.
- Rolling scars: Soft, wave-like dips. Treated with subcision, RF microneedling or fillers.
- Raised scars: Firm bumps above the skin. Treated with injections and silicone gel.
- Red or brown marks: Flat colour changes, not true scars. Treated with skincare, peels and sun protection.
- Most people: Have more than one scar type and need a combined plan
Why Does Scar Type Change the Treatment?
Acne scars form when deep inflammation damages collagen. Some scars sink because the skin loses collagen. Others rise because the skin makes too much. Each shape needs a different approach. A treatment suiting a wide, shallow scar does little for a narrow, deep one.
Your doctor examines your skin under side lighting to see the depth and edges of each scar. See the acne scar treatments page.
Which Acne Scar Types Exist?
| Scar Type | What You See | Depth | Common Treatments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ice pick | Narrow, deep holes like large pores | Deep | Focused acid treatment, fine needling |
| Boxcar | Round or oval dents with sharp edges | Shallow to medium | RF microneedling, laser resurfacing |
| Rolling | Wide dips with soft edges, wave-like surface | Medium | Subcision, RF microneedling, fillers |
| Hypertrophic | Firm, raised scar within the original spot | Raised | Steroid injections, silicone gel |
| Keloid | Raised scar spreading beyond the original spot | Raised | Steroid injections. Doctor assessment first. |
What Is the Difference Between Acne Marks and Acne Scars?
Many people call any mark left after a spot a scar. Flat marks are not true scars. The skin surface stays smooth.
- Red or purple marks: Leftover redness from inflammation. Common on lighter skin.
- Brown marks: Extra pigment after inflammation. Common on medium and darker skin.
Flat marks often fade over months with sun protection and skincare. Read melasma vs sun spots vs post-acne marks to tell them apart.
How Are Ice Pick Scars Treated?
Ice pick scars are narrow and deep. Surface treatments rarely reach the base. Options include:
- Focused acid treatment: Your doctor places a strong acid into each scar with a fine tool. The scar base heals upward over several sessions.
- Fine needling: Targets collagen in and around the scar
- Punch techniques: Your doctor removes a tiny circle of scar tissue and closes the skin. Suits a few deep scars.
How Are Boxcar Scars Treated?
Boxcar scars have sharp edges and a flat base. Treatments soften the edges and lift the base.
- RF microneedling: Fine needles deliver heat into the deeper skin and prompt new collagen. See RF microneedling.
- Laser resurfacing: Removes thin layers of skin to smooth edges
- Skin quality injectables: Support healing between sessions. Read salmon DNA for acne scars.
How Are Rolling Scars Treated?
Rolling scars form when bands of scar tissue pull the skin down from below. Releasing these bands comes first.
- Subcision: A fine needle cuts the bands under the skin, so the surface lifts
- RF microneedling: Builds collagen after release
- Fillers or collagen stimulators: Lift wide dips. Read the collagen stimulator guide.
How Are Raised Scars Treated?
Raised scars come from too much collagen. Treatment aims to flatten and soften them.
- Steroid injections: Flatten firm scars over several sessions, 4 to 6 weeks apart
- Silicone gel or sheets: Soften scars with daily use over months
- Laser: Reduces redness in raised scars
Keloid scars return easily after treatment. Your doctor plans these with extra care.
How Many Sessions Do You Need?
| Treatment | Typical Sessions | Spacing |
|---|---|---|
| RF microneedling | 3 to 4 | 4 to 6 weeks |
| Subcision | 1 to 3 | 4 to 8 weeks |
| Focused acid treatment | 3 to 6 | 4 to 6 weeks |
| Steroid injections for raised scars | 2 to 4 | 4 to 6 weeks |
| Skin quality injectables | 2 to 3 | 3 to 4 weeks |
Collagen keeps building for 3 to 6 months after each session. Your doctor reviews progress with photos.
When Should You Start Scar Treatment?
- Start once active acne is under control. New breakouts create new scars.
- Wait until your doctor reviews any oral acne medication you take or recently took
- Treat flat red and brown marks first with skincare and sun protection
- Start early. Younger scars often respond faster than old ones.
Is Scar Treatment Safe for Darker Skin?
Yes, with the right settings. Darker skin carries a higher risk of brown marks after heat or injury. Your doctor chooses settings and treatments with lower risk, such as RF microneedling over strong surface lasers. Read is RF microneedling safe for darker skin tones.
What Results Should You Expect?
- Scars soften and shadows reduce. Complete removal is rare.
- Most people see steady change over several months
- Combined treatments often give more change than a single method
- Daily SPF 50 protects new collagen and prevents marks darkening
What Should You Do After Treatment?
- Keep the skin clean and avoid makeup for 24 hours
- Skip active skincare such as retinoids and acids for 3 to 5 days
- Apply SPF 50 every morning and reapply outdoors
- Skip saunas, steam and intense exercise for 48 hours
- Do not pick or scratch flaking skin
Read RF microneedling aftercare for a full recovery timeline.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do acne scars fade on their own?
Flat red and brown marks often fade over months. Dented and raised scars stay without treatment.
Which treatment works for all scar types?
No single treatment suits every scar. Most plans combine two or more methods.
Is treating scars during active acne possible?
Your doctor controls active acne first. Some gentle treatments start alongside acne care.
Does treatment hurt?
Numbing cream keeps most treatments comfortable. Subcision uses local anaesthetic.
How long is the downtime?
Redness lasts 1 to 3 days after RF microneedling. Subcision leaves bruising for up to 1 week.
Do scars return after treatment?
Dented scars treated with collagen-building methods hold their improvement. Raised and keloid scars return more easily.
Related Guides
- RF Microneedling vs Microneedling
- RF Microneedling Aftercare
- Salmon DNA for Acne Scars
- Melasma vs Sun Spots vs Post-Acne Marks
- Is RF Microneedling Safe for Darker Skin Tones?
Book a Consultation
Not sure which scar types you have? Message us on WhatsApp to book your consultation.
This article is for general educational purposes and does not replace a personalised consultation with a licensed medical aesthetics provider. Individual results vary.




